| Platinum | Pizzicletta |
| Gold | Fat Olives |
| Silver | The Pizza Guy |
| Bronze | Pizza Edge |
| Top Pick | Elevated Pizza Co |
| Top Pick | Fratelli Pizza |
| Top Pick | Lumberjack Pizza |
| Top Pick | New Frontiers Natural Marketplace |
| Top Pick | New Jersey Pizza Co |
| Top Pick | Papa Murphy's Take N Bake Pizza |