| Platinum | Bow Wow Street Dogs & Grill |
| Gold | Flagstaff Brewing Company |
| Silver | In-N-Out Burger |
| Bronze | Mama Burger |
| Top Pick | Brown Bag Burger + Bar Flagstaff, AZ |
| Top Pick | Five Guys Burgers & Fries |
| Top Pick | Lucy's Burgers |
| Top Pick | Proper Meats + Provisions |
| Top Pick | Shift Kitchen & Bar |